Independent reviews of baseball and softball pitching machines, matched to age, ball and backyardHow we make money
Comparison

JUGS vs Heater: Which Pitching Machine Brand Should You Buy?

JUGS is the brand you see at high school fields. Heater is the one in most backyards. Both make good machines for different budgets.

Buy JUGS for accuracy, durability and digital speed control if you can spend $1,000 or more; buy Heater for the most speed, features and feeders per dollar, especially under $800.

Updated November 19, 2026 · By the editors of Pitching Machine Report · We earn from qualifying purchases

MachineTop speedFeederWarrantyPrice
Heater Junior48 mph baseballsHolds 12, one every 10 secondsNot listedAbout $300
Heater Real Baseball52 mph baseballsOptionalNot listedAbout $400
Heater Combo60 mph baseballs, 56 mph softballsAutomatic feeder includedNot listedAbout $650
Heater Deuce 7575 mph baseballsHolds 121 yearAbout $800
JUGS PS5050 mph baseballs, 50 mph softballsOptional1 yearAbout $995
JUGS BP170 mph baseballsOptional carousel feeder2 yearsAbout $1,950

Build and accuracy

JUGS machines use steel frames, digital speed readouts and pneumatic tires, and they're known for throwing the same strike for hours. Heater's real-ball machines range from the lighter Junior to the all-metal Real Baseball; they're solid, but speed is set by a dial rather than a readout, so settings are less repeatable.

Features per dollar

Heater wins on value. For about $650, the Heater Combo throws baseballs and softballs and includes a feeder. For about $800, the Deuce 75 throws curves. JUGS's closest machine, the PS50, costs about $995 without a feeder and tops out at 50 mph.

Which to buy

  • JUGS PS50 for a family machine that lasts through several kids.
  • JUGS BP1 for teams that need 70 mph every day.
  • Heater Real Baseball for real balls on a budget.
  • Heater Combo for two sports with a feeder.
  • Heater Deuce 75 for curves under $1,000.

Questions

Is JUGS better than Heater?

JUGS is better built and more precise. Heater gives you more speed, more features and included feeders for less money.

Who makes the most accurate pitching machine?

JUGS has the strongest reputation for accuracy among home and team machines.

Keep reading